Page 1 of 3

maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 12:28 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
As above. How many can I consume? They seem like a great portable,palatable and affordable source of everyday protein.
$1.80 for 225g can with 30g protein.
If it's ok, I'll eat 2-3 cans a day.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 12:31 pm
by galapogos

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 1:03 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
salmon, 1 can of tuna and 1 can of sardine everyday. Prob will cause mercury poisoning for me since 225g of sardine x7 = ~49 ounces is already 40% of the EHA limit.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 3:57 pm
by Weib
sardine by itself taste like shit.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 4:35 pm
by Sufian
obviously u are lying.

Sardines are the best testing fish in a can. Much better tasting than tuna by itself. Trust me, I am hardcore on these stuffs. Louis is mentally weak when it comes to food. Haha.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 4:48 pm
by Weib
yesh, my taste buds has not died and i'm a foodie at heart.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 7:51 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
Sufian wrote:obviously u are lying.

Sardines are the best testing fish in a can. Much better tasting than tuna by itself. Trust me, I am hardcore on these stuffs. Louis is mentally weak when it comes to food. Haha.
They're ok to me, except tt they leave a horrible smell in your mouth after. Ditto for Tuna.

How many cans of sardine and tuna do you recommend i eat a day Sufian?

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:02 pm
by Sufian
i have no fixed number. I have eaten 7 cans of tuna (with light mayo) per day for 3 consecutive days during camp last year. Nothing funky showed up in the preceeding blood test.

Everyone is different. Heck, if ur mum can afford the grass fed beef, why even think of tuna?

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:34 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
Sufian wrote:i have no fixed number. I have eaten 7 cans of tuna (with light mayo) per day for 3 consecutive days during camp last year. Nothing funky showed up in the preceeding blood test.

Everyone is different. Heck, if ur mum can afford the grass fed beef, why even think of tuna?
I hope to reach at least 1.25kg or even 1.5kg of meat a day. currently I think I'm eating prob around 800g or 1kg only.
Even if we can afford grass fed beef, I can't possibly be eating it everyday. $17 per kg per week. roughly 200g a day.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:44 pm
by galapogos
Mercury and other pollutants accumulate over years. You don't just get it from chugging tuna 3 days in a row. You can do that once in a while but long term wise I would definitely not recommend it. And choose red tuna over white if you're eating a lot of tuna.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:49 pm
by Sufian
my sentiments exactly, Goi.

I would not recommend cans and cans of tuna everyday. But, it sure is an easy way to bring your food. Cheap even.

And, dont get freaking obsessed with xx amount of meat per day please.

Train hard, eat hard. REst hard. Dont think too much.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:01 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
galapogos wrote:Mercury and other pollutants accumulate over years. You don't just get it from chugging tuna 3 days in a row. You can do that once in a while but long term wise I would definitely not recommend it. And choose red tuna over white if you're eating a lot of tuna.
What's red tuna? hm. I think I shall go for 4-5 cans a week in that case. Alt sardine and salmon.

Just used the advanced calculator on the website. with 4 cans of tuna, 4 x230g of salmon, and 5 cans of sardine each week, my mercury DHA lvl is 220% of the maximum.

Shit.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:25 pm
by Weib
if so troublesome, then just eat chicken la.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:28 pm
by galapogos
Sufian wrote:my sentiments exactly, Goi.

I would not recommend cans and cans of tuna everyday. But, it sure is an easy way to bring your food. Cheap even.

And, dont get freaking obsessed with xx amount of meat per day please.

Train hard, eat hard. REst hard. Dont think too much.
Well, if he's following Coach Jon's advice and he asks him to eat xx amount of meat per day, then I suggest he do it, and ignore everything else we say. Because too many cooks in the kitchen spoils the broth...

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:58 pm
by Weib
actually i'm curious 1.5kg of meat seems rather vague - 1.5 of ribeye vs lean chicken the caloric and micronutrients seems off by alot.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 10:05 pm
by Ryan.carpediem
Weib wrote:actually i'm curious 1.5kg of meat seems rather vague - 1.5 of ribeye vs lean chicken the caloric and micronutrients seems off by alot.
How so? JW actually told me i can sub some of the meat with eggs but they are inferior as meat is absorbed slower. However, he said almonds and shakes are out as substitutes. :(

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 10:28 pm
by AhBen
Sufian wrote:
Train hard, eat hard. REst hard. Dont think too much.
We said this so so many many times liao... :lol:

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 10:56 pm
by Weib
I think you should ask JW whats the caloric requirement and micro nutrient break down to be precise.
TBH its going to be disastrous with such vague recommendation.

If you do the math 1.5kg of ribeye is like 3000 calories, while 1.5kg of lean chicken is 2475, tuna will be 1736 and eggs will be 2327.

as you can see the vast difference is caloric intake notwithstanding the micro nutrients, if you're 85kg then the rib eye will be your maintenance, the lean chicken and eggs with be moderate deficit and tuna will be rapid fat loss protocol.

Since you know you're not a newbie in nutrition, i believe you should get a exact figure and stick to it.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 11:10 pm
by aaron
louis why dont you just let ryan do it, i think he has enough questions without you actually providing him with more like wth lol.

ryan, chicken makes you weak lol if you can just eat beef or whatever you can get. eat and rest and stop thinking lol.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 10:24 am
by Ryan.carpediem
aaron wrote:louis why dont you just let ryan do it, i think he has enough questions without you actually providing him with more like wth lol.

ryan, chicken makes you weak lol
louis: asked him about it he said just vary the meat, he said all tuna is bad but sardine is ok as it's small fish. 1.5kg is supposed to be guide i think,JW: "you won't die if u eat 1.4kg, 1.6kg but if u eat 0.5kg u are sucking " :shock:

aaron: why does chicken make one weak?

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 10:28 am
by galapogos
Ryan.carpediem wrote:
aaron wrote:louis why dont you just let ryan do it, i think he has enough questions without you actually providing him with more like wth lol.

ryan, chicken makes you weak lol
louis: asked him about it he said just vary the meat, he said all tuna is bad but sardine is ok as it's small fish. 1.5kg is supposed to be guide i think, "you won't die if u eat 1.4kg, 1.6kg but if u eat 0.5kg u are sucking" :shock:

aaron: why does chicken make one weak?
i'm definitely sucking then :(

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 11:00 am
by xarope
Ryan.carpediem wrote:louis: asked him about it he said just vary the meat, he said all tuna is bad but sardine is ok as it's small fish. 1.5kg is supposed to be guide i think, "you won't die if u eat 1.4kg, 1.6kg but if u eat 0.5kg u are sucking" :shock:
Then I sux big time too, since i barely eat more than 400-600gm of meat a day (e.g. yesterday had a chicken chop for lunch, and rib eye for dinner, so probably 400-500gm).

I think this whole 1.5kg of meat a day is completely blown out of proportion, as is the carb intolerence issue. If you are drastically overweight or have high BF%, it's because you eat too much and most of it junk, and don't workout hard enough. You guys are young and healthy, yet your entire week's workouts barely constitute a morning's work for the whole week, if you were a farmer, steel worker etc.

Westside protocol advocates ME days followed by 2 sets of max reps (or at least 15-20)... I don't know why you guys can complain about high reps, might as well stop walking then, your legs might shrink with all those "high reps".

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 11:24 am
by galapogos
xarope wrote:I don't know why you guys can complain about high reps
Coz I suck at high reps :(

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 12:05 pm
by Weib
west side isn't really big on body comp lol
again i'll advise to get the exact micro nutrient break down/caloric limit

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 12:14 pm
by xarope
Weib wrote:west side isn't really big on body comp lol
again i'll advise to get the exact micro nutrient break down/caloric limit
I'm talking about people throwing around heavy weights, who advocate both low and high reps, whereas a lot of the young guys on this forum seem to fixate on only doing low reps.

You, too, suffer(ed?) from a work capacity issue.

My semi-rant on that topic had nothing to do with body comp, although if you have the work capacity (which most don't), then body comp is strictly then about diet.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 12:22 pm
by Weib
well it does affect some how, higher intensity would require a certain amount of glycogen to keep he intensity up but you need to train towards expanding your lactic threshold limit and psychological barrier of the pain that entails with pushing the threshold.

i won't say good or bad but rather what is the ultimate goal, but i'll always believe if you train for performance your body comp will be the byproduct rather than the emphasis as oppose to bodybuilding.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 1:26 pm
by AhBen
Westside does not neglect high reps and conditioning. That's why there is a focus on RE work and sled pulling for GPP as well.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 9:53 pm
by Sufian
I have trouble using up my work capacity. Serious. I think i started too much too soon. Body adapted too early.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 10:01 pm
by galapogos
Sufian wrote:I have trouble using up my work capacity. Serious. I think i started too much too soon. Body adapted too early.
Then lift heavier.

Re: maximum cans of sardine a day

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 10:23 pm
by Sufian
I dont think I lift that light to begin with.